A blueprint for the C.D.C. to bring children back to classrooms safely.
By Tracy Beth Høeg, Monica Gandhi and Daniel Johnson
Dr. Høeg is a physician and an epidemiologist at the University of California, Davis. Dr. Gandhi is a professor of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, and the director of the U.C.S.F. Center for AIDS Research. Dr. Johnson is a professor of pediatrics and the chief of pediatric infectious diseases at the University of Chicago Medicine.
As American children conclude what will hopefully be the most discombobulated academic year of their lives, it’s clear that school must be different this fall. Thanks to increasing vaccinations and declining rates of Covid-19 infections, children can safely return to classrooms. To facilitate this, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention should release a blueprint for reopening schools that balances the countless benefits of in-person schooling with the lower risks of Covid-19 to children and (mostly vaccinated) teachers and staff.
Since the pandemic began, Covid-19 has affected children less than adults, and the risk the disease poses to youths is diminishing as vaccinations increase. Children are about half as likely as adults to spread the coronavirus, and long Covid appears to be uncommon in children. Research in Wisconsin, North Carolina, Utah and New York City has shown that children can be welcomed back to classrooms without substantial viral outbreaks. Leaders in New York City and New Jersey have already said that their schools will reopen fully this fall.
As physicians who study infectious disease and epidemiology, we believe that the best way to prevent Covid-19 from spreading in schools is to vaccinate the adults — teachers, staff and parents — throughout the school. When more people in a community are protected against the coronavirus, unprotected people, such as the children who aren’t yet able to get vaccinated, are less likely to be exposed.
Children ages 12 and older should be encouraged to get immunized, and vaccines are likely to be available for younger children this fall. However, students don’t need to be segregated by vaccination status, nor should they be required to get vaccinated when they return to school. After all, Israel fully reopened schools after Covid-19 surges earlier this year, and cases among children remained low even though no one under the age of 16 had been vaccinated.
The coronavirus will likely still be circulating at low levels this fall, so schools cannot simply operate as they did before the pandemic. But some of the sanitation measures that institutions embraced early in the pandemic have not been found to be effective, so school districts should focus on the tactics that work against transmitting the virus. School staff should frequently clean surfaces that are touched regularly, but the widespread use of antimicrobial cleaning products is unnecessary and could lead to antimicrobial resistance. Many schools have installed plexiglass barriers between desks, but these don’t effectively prevent the spread of the coronavirus and may create obstacles to learning and communication. Schools can also stop taking the temperatures of students when they arrive, as this has not proved to be a reliable screening tool for Covid-19.
Source: Read Full Article