Russian state TV pundits clash over military action in Ukraine
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you’ve consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. More info
Pro-Western politician Boris Nadezhdin made a surprise appearance on NTV over the weekend calling for peace talks. Mr Nadezhdin, who has often played the role of a token liberal on Russian State television, said that Russia could not win the way using the current resources available.
He said: “We’re not at the point where we have to understand – it’s absolutely impossible to defeat Ukraine, using the resources and colonial war methods that Russia is using to win this war.
“I’m suggesting peace talks to end this war.”
Mr Nadezhdin added that he thought that the Russian President was being lied to by his aides about the progress of the war.
Although most commentators on Russian state television are pro-Kremlin, frustration is beginning to boil over about the lack of progress and heavy losses in Ukraine.
Some analysts have suggested that by allowing liberals such as Mr Nadezhdin to air their views Putin is testing the waters for potential negotiations with Ukraine.
Speaking to The Daily Telegraph from Moscow, Andrei Kolesnikov, a senior fellow at Carnegie Endowment for International Peace described the comments as “extraordinary” and said that they could be a way to “let off steam” by legitimising criticism of the war effort.
He said: “Either this was a mistake or it’s a deliberate attempt to let off steam and even prime the audience to at least the possibility of peace talks.
“This is quite an extraordinary event.”
However, some hard line Russian nationalists have called for mass mobilisation and the continuation of the conflict in the wake of Ukraine’s success on the battlefield.
Alexander Kazakov, a pro-Kremlin MP, warned Mr Nadezhdin on the show that his comments could breach Russian war censorship rules and insisted that Moscow would wage the war until its objectives were met.
In response Mr Nadezhdin quipped: “So my 10-year-old kids will get a chance to fight, is that right?”
Another commentator on the show argued that Kremlin spin doctors were at fault for claiming that it was a fluke that Ukraine was an independent nation and a product of Bolshevik imagination.
Putin’s army on brink of anarchy as troops turn guns on one another [REVEAL]
Putin sacks General just 17 days after appointing him – army in chaos [INSIGHT]
‘Do you still think you can scare us?’: Zelensky mocks Putin [SPOTLIGHT]
Russian Sunday night TV news shows ignored the retreat from the Kharkiv region or explained it as a strategic move to save Russian lives.
Igor Girkin, a former Russian commander of Ukrainian separatists, is among the hardliners calling for an enhanced offensive, although he blamed Putin for recent losses.
Mr Girkin praised airstrikes on civilian infrastructure across Ukraine and warned that Kyiv’s possible response “will hopefully make Kremlin residents of Planet of Pink Ponies realise that this is a total war, and it needs to be won without any illusions about a peace deal on equal terms”.
There has been increased speculation about the possibility of a general mobilisation, however, Alexander Khodakovsky, a former senior separatist commander in Donetsk, warned that such a move could backfire.
He said: “The reason why this is happening is not a shortage of men but a bad use of them.
“If we carry on like this, we will keep on lacking manpower no matter how many men you mobilise while Russia will be swept with death notices, which will lead to a crisis.”
Source: Read Full Article